"It's plain and simple: people don't want to open Red Cards!"
LOL. They just don't KNOW that they want to open a Red Card.
Here are my tips:
Sell to every guest. Don't wait for the prompt or you'll miss lots of opportunities.
Don't wait until the transaction is complete to start talking about the Red Card. As soon as the guest starts unloading, ask if they are familiar with the Red Card.
Try to avoid using the word "credit." That scares 'em off.
If they say they are familiar with the Red card and they don't want it, explain that we now have the option of attaching the Card to their checking account - it works just like the debit card they're using today, except they save 5%, get free shipping from Target.com with no minimum and we donate 1% of all your purchases to the school of your choice. And there are no transaction fees or annual fees like the bank's card. Tout the fact that they can shop online and if the item doesn't fit, it can be returned to the Target store - no hassles. And think of the things you can ship to your college kid - no shipping fees, no hassle with returns.
Or if they have a stack of coupons, point out that the Red Card is an extra 5% coupon that they don't have to clip; it stays in their pocket and can be used every time they come to Target.
Or if the guest is pregnant, remind her that with the new baby coming, there will be lots of additional expenses with diapers, formula, clothes, strollers, and stuff. Wouldn't it be nice to save that 5%? Hey, you could even start a savings account with that 5% for your child's college education. It really adds up quickly.
Or if they're buying alcohol, mention that an extra 5% adds up quickly and there's no minimum purchase to get a discount like there is at the liquor store. You know, the liquor store requires you to buy a case to get a discount, right?
Always thank the guest who is using his/her Red Card loudly and point out their year to date savings. I've sold so many Red Cards to the next guest after hearing the guest brag about how much she's saved.
As a GSA/GSTL, when you're checking ID on alcohol sales for a minor, try this: BTW, did "cashier" remember to tell you about our Red Card? Then go into the savings spiel. It's a great way to teach your younger, less experienced cashiers how to sell and it gives them the confidence to try some of the tips. Modeling works better for me than one on one off the lane teaching.
Is it fun selling Red Cards? Not always. But consider it a game and compete with yourself.