Ugh one time someone at the service desk made an entire pack of Gatorade a toss just because ONE bottle was leaking. I don't know if there's a way to requisition the other bottles or at least donate them but surely there's another option besides putting it in the toss cart?
My store may not be good for much else, but when something like this happens we always just give it to the guy who's in charge of our donations. He'll process out what can't be sold/used and donate the rest. But this only works if people (BR, flow, and sales floor) actually knew the procedures. Oh well.