I just spend like a good 15+ minutes on the phone with Target Benefits, Optium Bank, and UHC. The consensus is I should have the money in there, but because the new plan started on 04/01, the online balances haven't updated yet. Hopefully that's the case, if not, then I'm missing a fairly significant sum of money.
Target Benefits says they are deducting the money and show that the money should be in the account (online it shows $00.00), UHC says the HSA has nothing to do with them, and Optium Bank says the just manage the account.